Request advice
+31 77 20 577 25
Steerable, controllable and data driven turf management
  • Steerable, controllable and data driven turf pitch management
  • Better Grass at Lower Cost
  • Request advice: +31 77 20 577 25

energy efficiency stogger LED vs HPS SON-T

In turf lighting practice the distribution of assimilation light within the grass growlight market is one of the most discussed issues. Since lighting costs, and thus energy, do not seem to stop increasing, an efficient use of assimilation light is of considerable importance for fieldmanagers. Many suppliers still use HPS SON-T. We focus at applying Mechatronix LED grow lights. Why did we made this decision?
• Morphologic faster rooting and stronger vegetative growth
• Higher light level possible, shorter treatment
• Early season light treatment start possible
• Initial investment payback period <3 years
• Energy efficient. Limited main connection necessary
• 70% light efficiency
• Energy efficiency of 3.5 µmol/J
• 10 years warranty, maintenance free
• World-class optics; even light distribution for homogeneic  growth 
• State-of-the-art technology; allows to profit from new developments
• Dynamic lighting: soft start/stop, like the sun
• Creates low heat. If heat is needed, burning gas is > 2x cheaper
• Turf morphology not steerable by spectrum
• Higher light level not possible, because of tipburn
• Limited initial investment
• Energy intensive. Requires industrial main connection & feed lines
• 35% light efficiency
• Energy efficiency of 2.1 µmol/J 
• Replace lamps every 3 years, maintenance required
• Less effective optics; more uneven light distribution resulting in "grass growth spots" 
• End of life technology
• Static lighting: on/off
• Creates a lot of heat: high inefficiency and risk of tipburn

Why not use HPS SON-T?

While the efficiency and technology of HPS SON-T grow lights has stabilized over years, the efficiency of LED grow lights moves up every year. Just a few years ago we could still discuss if LED grow lights would offer a major advantage over the well-known and proven, but very limited lifetime technology of HPS SON-T lamps.

Today it is clear that the future of turf assimilation lighting has completely turned in the direction of LED technology. The most important cost driver of any grass grow solution is energy efficiency. Due to it's proven track-record, the only way to go is a LED powered solution. The cost savings make sure that within 2 years a LED system is cheaper than SON-T. 
In turf lighting practice the distribution of assimilation light within the grass growlight market is one of the most discussed issues. Since lighting costs, and thus energy, do not seem to stop increasing, an efficient use of assimilation light is of considerable importance for fieldmanagers. Many suppliers still use HPS SON-T. We focus at applying Mechatronix LED grow lights. Why did we made this decision?
Mechatronix CoolStack

10 year LED warranty

We designed our Booster's with more than just another LED grow light. We used the Mechatronix Coolstack®, with a market leading efficacy up to 3.6µmol/J, as it is a state-of-the-art grow light platform with an unprecedented level of technology and vision in it. As an example, we equip our Booster's with the first sustainable LED grow light on the market. With a 10 year warranty and LED life time of 75.000 lighting hours this stand equivalent to 20 years of use at a yearly rate of 3.600 hours of deployment. Of course in that time the technology and efficiency of LED grow lights will drastically change and improve, and your energy cost is one of the major aspects.

Therefore, the CoolStack® is designed in such a way that the LED grow light engines can be replaced and updated over time.
Did you know that the LED engines only count for 35% of the total cost of a grow light, and that the expectations are that this percentage will further decline over time when the LEDs become cheaper?
So why would you throw away 100% of a LED lamp after your warranty period when you want to upgrade to the next level of market efficiency in grow lights while you could do that with just a small part of the cost?
This is how we contribute, not only in your current investment, but also securing your durable future!
Booster 70C picture bottom

Cost Calculation Example

We provide grass grow light solutions for the lowest cost of ownership. To demonstrate in practice what that means, we have made a cost comparison calculation example below for HPS SON-T vs LED.
The calculation is based on a closed stadium like the Johan Cruijff Arena with a very minimum of sunlight all-year long. In a more open stadium or at different kWh rates, savings are different. Contact us for a cost calculation for your specific situation.
SON-T - 200 m2 grass @ 410 µmol/s/m2
Initial investment: HPS SON-T (2.100 µmol/s)
€ 8.200
Energy consumption per year (€ 0,20/kWh)
€ 41.519
HPS SON-T replacement costs each 18.000 hours
€ 3.550
Total costs after 3 years
€ 135.711
Total costs after 5 years
€ 220.666
Total costs after 10 years
€ 433.055
Stogger LED - 200 m2 grass @ 410 µmol/s/m2
CoolStack® LED equivalent (3.485 µmol/s)
€ 27.200
Energy consumption per year (€ 0,20/kWh)
€ 19.200
No LED replacement costs: 10 year warranty
€ 0
Total costs after 3 years
€ 84.844
Total costs after 5 years
€ 123.244
Total costs after 10 years
€ 219.244
10 year total cost of ownership savings (€ 1.069 /m2)
€ 213.811

Request a turf care advice

Are you looking to achieve healthier and stronger turf growth year-round, while also enhancing game quality and reducing injury risks?

We can help you reach your goals through data monitoring and cutting-edge LED technology. With our innovative approach, we offer to be your reliable partner in a wide range of turf care and grow light solutions.

Find us online

Contact

Stogger Engineering BV
Maasbreeseweg 55a
5981 NB Panningen
the Netherlands
info@stadiumgrowlight.com

Part of

In close cooperation with

Mechatronix logo grey

Copyright Stogger 2022

Contact us
Call Now
Bel Pieter!
Call Now
crossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram